As I previously described I have sometimes bought or sold shares of stock in a company based upon little more than a poorly researched belief accompanied by a heightened state of excitement or anxiety.

YOU know the scenario, the mentality: “I better sell (this stock) now!” “I better buy shares now!” Why? Because “I believe . . . “.

Heck, it’s not even that you or I have a clear “I believe” thought. It’s often more a affect, an urge to impulse, to “do this now”: buy, sell, now . . tomorrow may be too late.

There should be a sign on your PC’s monitor or on your tablet that reads “ONLY buy stock “now” after you have slept on that conclusion for 24 hours”.

What stock to buy or to invest in REQUIRES more careful research and analysis than “now” can ever offer. “Buy now” is the siren call to stock investing suckers, sirens being those maidens who called sailors to steer their ships into the rocks.

When is the last time you read 2-3 years worth of financial statements before buying or selling a stock?

When is the last time you investigated industry trade journals that might have a clearer picture of emerging trends?

When is the last time you bothered to research the various government websites whose job it is to predict market trends for the purpose of fashioning public policy or informing decision makers?

When is the last time you labored to test or “reality check” the assumptions underlying your impulse to invest in a company?

I will only call myself a “rational investor”, going forward, when I have undertaken at least half of the following steps:

  • Read at least a random sample of 4-6 quarterly financial reports of a company spanning the past 3+ years
  • Compared at least 4-6 summaries of conference calls during the past 3+ years, to see if there’s a disconnect between projections and outcomes
  • Scanned online message boards ONLY to gain insight into the efforts being invested in pumping a stock, up or down
  • Scanned the professional journals for any degree of insight about trends affecting any company or industry
  • Checked one or more government sources for information or data about an industry
  • Looked at the major institutional stock holders for patterns of stock sales or purchases
  • Look at insider trading for the past 24 months
  • Look at the real world for signs of real momentum favoring or disfavoring an industry
  • Slept on the accumlated data and information for at least 24 hours
  • Look at the company’s stock price charts for the past 5 years, 1 year and 6 months to see what connection(s) may exist between the stock price, the market as a whole, and company specific news
  • Sleep for 24 more hours after looking at the charts
  • Look for signs of recent price bottoms and price support
  • Question what could pull out the bottom
  • Ask myself “Is this really the best alternative for where to invest my money, now?”
  • Sleep on it again and don’t ever act when I’m not well rested
  • Decide on an entry point for my stock purchase, based upon all of the above, AND an EXIT PRICE
  • Then sit back, wait for the market to backslide – as it does so often anymore – and only THEN make a stock purchase.
  • And last, but not least, sell the darned stock at the pre-agreed (with myself) price, and it that’s on the upside BE HAPPY and don’t second guess myself

The most rational investments I have made have been those that have followed the above pattern.

The most rational investments I have made have had both a well thought out entry point and an equally well thought out exit price.

Lastly, the most rational – and successful – investments I have made are those where I respected and followed my own thoroughly thought out advice, both as to entry price point or stock purchase price and exit price.

Do this. Take your profits when they are there to be had. And don’t look back.

Except to help judge when you will next enter back into the market for a given comopany’s stock.

After a sound night’s sleeep.

Investment decisions should be well researched. Stock trades should follow careful analysis and trades should be executed with a cool hand and cool head.

Does that describe your investing style? Does it describe mine?

No, probably not for many readers and, unfortunately, not always for me.

So, what to do? How can we all be more rational investors?

Well, maybe we can start by comparing the mentality, mind and actions of emotional investors with those of more rational, controlled and analytical investors.

Here’s a short list of what may describe my “emotional investing moments”:

  • I invested based upon belief, in brand or company, without deeper research of recent and long term fundamentals
  • I acted because I thought or assumed something positive was evolving, without sleeping on the decision to buy or sell and fully considering the basis of the assumption
  • I bought or sold stock when I was tired or under stress
  • I made a decision without reading financial statements
  • I acted based upon news alone
  • I acted based upon “eyeballed momentum”
  • I followed the herd without a clear understanding of the make up of the stock buying herd
  • I acted on perceived versus investigated value of a company
  • I bought because I believed a stock would go up
  • I sold because I feared that a stock would go down

The fundamental or universal quality of almost every stock purchase or sale that I have made, which buying or selling of shares I would describe as emotional acts, was that my actions were based upon little more than a half-reasoned, half-resarched belief often accompanied by a state of heightened excitement or anxiety.

Pulling Out of the Stockmarket Before or After Congress Defaults on the National Debt

Thumbnail image for Pulling Out of the Stockmarket Before or After Congress Defaults on the National Debt

In the game known as “chicken” the outcome – winning and losing – is based upon someone being sane. If both parties to the game are crazy then, depending on how you look at it, either no one wins (It’s a tie!) or both get to be winners, as neither was “chicken”. There is a [...]

Read the full article →

TIAA-CREF Client Customer Service – Part 1

Thumbnail image for TIAA-CREF Client Customer Service – Part 1

This is about my interaction with TIAA-CREF, one of the largest financial services firms in the retirement savings and investment sector. Having to process a surivor benefits claim for retirement account funds is, to be honest, an unhappy reminder. It is evocative. It evokes the feelings, emotions, pains of one’s life. The very term “survivor” [...]

Read the full article →

Investing for a Few Days or Weeks in Up and Down Stocks

Thumbnail image for Investing for a Few Days or Weeks in Up and Down Stocks

A friend recently advised that his friend, a retired skilled tradesman, has been playing the same stock, over and over, and making more than a few bucks doing it. When I asked the name of the stock I had to smile, as I had recently benefited from playing the same game, with the same stock. [...]

Read the full article →

Bullish or BullShirt – DJI From March 2009 to July 2011

Thumbnail image for Bullish or BullShirt – DJI From March 2009 to July 2011

March 2009 – Dow Jones Industrial (DJI) average approaches 6600. July 2011 – DJI approximately 12,500. Really? The stock market moves up 6000 points? So the downward swing or 6,000 points reflected nothing but . . irrational pessimism? People were overly nervous about immiment bank failures due to a foreclosure crisis? So the market panicked? [...]

Read the full article →

Goldman Sachs and Facebook – Screw Up or Win Win

So it’s all over the news: Goldman Sachs’ “attempt” to offer shares of Facebook, in a private placement with some of its mega-clients, has been halted. To borrow a line from Seinfeld, for Goldman Sachs’ American clients, it’s now a case of “No shares for you!” Now it’s time to speculate about just how smart [...]

Read the full article →

Money In The Bank Or Money In Bank Stocks

We all likely know someone, a member of an older generation, who did well putting a steady stream of cash into bank deposits over a long period of time. Many of these folks were products of the “Great Depression” and thus, did not trust the stock market. I would like to do the same but [...]

Read the full article →